Review of Tosca. The Art of Resistance

English National Opera

 

 

Director Annilese Miskimmon’s radical Tosca is a long way from its original 19th century Napoleonic context.  Her powerful concept sets the opera in 1980s Soviet Poland.  Here the Church triples a place of intrigue, a tyrant’s bedroom and a killing field.

Dramatic action is layered throughout the evening by the subtle suggestion of transgenerational trauma.  This is done by the inclusion of a chorus from Marlborough Primary School.  The narrative drive of Tosca’s desire to save her lover Cavaradossi, her almost-seduction by Scarpia and her transition from victim to killer, is seen by innocent witnesses.  This makes us, as audience, think about how powerless bystanders can become collaborators.  A boy, about to deliver a bouquet to Scarpia, the Chief of Police, is forced to become his malicious agent.  Another boy witnesses physical violence but can do nothing.  This adds to the dramatic and psychological reading of the work.

French soprano, Axelle Fanyo makes her ENO debut as Tosca.  Her compelling voice is huge, warm and dramatic.  Matching her is Chaz’men Williams-Ali as Cavaradossi and Christopher Purves as Scarpia.  The orchestra, conducted by Ben Glassberg played Puccini’s exquisite score with punch and pathos.

The thrill of this production is certainly in the quality of the orchestra, the singers and the ensemble.  But the hand of the director, and her creative team, is pleasingly evident.  Miskimmon ‘paints’ the stage with unexpected bursts of movement.  The fluidity of the action, and the imagination of the vision, make this exciting scenography.  But the greatest shock is the ending which astounds the audience with its extraordinary coup de théâtre.  Brava!

Julia Pascal © 2026.

   
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (026).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (047).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (076).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (079).
Tristan Meziere, Christopher Purves, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (031).
Alaric Green, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (016).
Axelle Fanyo, Chaz'men Williams-Ali, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (005).
Axelle Fanyo, Chaz-men Williams-Ali, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (010).
Axelle Fanyo, Christopher Purves, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (049).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (029).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (037).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (048).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (052).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (053).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (060).
Chaz'men Williams-Ali, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (004).
Chaz-men Williams-Ali, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (014).
Christopher Purves, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (025).
Christopher Purves, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (032).
Christopher Purves, Osian Wyn Bowen, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (033).
Christopher Purves, Robert Hayward, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (023).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (001).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (017).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (018).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (020).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (022).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (026).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (047).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (076).
The Cast of ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (079).
Tristan Meziere, Christopher Purves, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (031).
Alaric Green, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (016).
Axelle Fanyo, Chaz'men Williams-Ali, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (005).
Axelle Fanyo, Chaz-men Williams-Ali, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (010).
Axelle Fanyo, Christopher Purves, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (049).
Axelle Fanyo, ENO’s Tosca 2026 © Ellie Kurttz (029).